It can be easy to feel like we’re somehow “left out” of this. ." Why Did God Choose Circumcision? September. Circumcision was the sign of God’s covenant with Abraham (Gen 17:9–14), but it was also widely practiced in the ancient Near East (the method, though, wasn’t always the same). Circumcision signed the Jewish babies as members of the chosen people of God. Sign Up For Our Newsletter
Jesus revealed God's nature in himself to be non-violent. He … H uman beings can live as God intended only if flesh is put to death. Circumcision was meant to be a sign of God’s covenant with humans. Bible Study Magazine published by Faithlife Corporation. Why did God Choose Circumcision? Nevertheless, it would be through Sarah’s womb (Gen 17:21; 18:14) that God would fulfill His promise of innumerable offspring to Abraham (Gen 12:1–3). In the New Testament, membership in God’s family is “circumcision neutral” (Gal 5:6). When God told Abraham to be circumcised, he was past the age of bearing children and his wife, Sarah, was incapable of having children (Gen 18:11). While God did choose Abraham’s descendants as His chosen nation, we see that even in this first giving of circumcision, God welcomed non-Jews into His family. How did circumcision start in the Bible? If they surrendered their foreskins, they gained inclusion. The flood is the first great exemplification of this theme, as Yahweh’s Spirit wearies of the struggle with flesh (Gen. 6:3) and grieves over the damage to creation (Gen. 6:6–7), the violence that flesh invariably produces (Gen. 6:13). 0 0. As to foreshadowing Christ’s birth, God had promised Abraham offspring in the covenant. But neither does circumcision seem to be a proof or symbol of God’s activity, or a sign to remind God of his obligations (cf. While circumcision served as a permanent reminder to Israel that they needed to obey God's laws, the fact that a man was circumcised did not mean he actually kept the law. " The traditional answer to why Jews circumcise their sons is that the ceremony marks the covenant between God and Abraham. In the Old Testament God gave Laws to the Israelites which could apply to both their practical life and to the spiritual life. In opposing flesh, Yahweh is not opposing humanity. However, I will address that issue. Religions and other groups have used many ways of marking their own throughout history, Why did God choose circumcision for His people? There is no definitive answer as to why God choose circumcision as a sign of the covenant between God and the Jewish people. Everyone in Abraham’s household witnessed the miracle of Isaac’s birth. But some cultures want an outward sign of the religion imposed on them, such as tattoos, attire, and even female circumcision. I am doing some research on this subject. Sign up to receive offers from Logos Bible Software! The hopeful, beautiful, and terrible reason for the drastic covenant. Some adherents to the God of Israel in the Second Temple period reasoned that gentiles too could choose to worship this God. (Women only have to immerse.) Most of my adult life, I have wondered why God chose circumcision — what did it signify? According to the Torah and Halakha (Jewish religious law), ritual circumcision of all male Jews and their slaves (Genesis 17:10–13) is a commandment from God that Jews are obligated to perform on the eighth day of birth, and is only postponed or abrogated in the case of threat to the life or health of the child. It probably didn’t make any sense, though, until Sarah became pregnant. In the flood, Yahweh wipes the world clean of all flesh (Gen. 6:13, 17; 7:21). It is faith in Christ, not a Jewish identity signified by circumcision, that makes someone part of the Church. According to this interpretation, the penis could be seen as a symbol of human desires and urges. Why Circumcision? 1 decade ago. Rooted in the understanding of humanity at the time was the idea that only males were fully human and that women, due to their gender, were not. Bible Study Magazine is the only award-winning magazine devoted to making your Bible Study more effective, organized, and relevant. “Jews” is used over 85 times in Acts and almost without exception refers to unbelievers. Circumcision is a fraud and a hoax. One I ask was about circumcision, . 8 comments: Bradley Wilson September 23, 2011 at 5:57 PM. The evidence suggests that circumcision did not distinguish Israelite men from their foreign neighbors. Copyright 2019 Faithlife / Bible Study Magazine. CTWeekly delivers the best content from ChristianityToday.com to your inbox each week. From that point on, every male understood why they had been circumcised: Their entire race—their very existence—began with a miraculous act of God. The graphic symbolism is the reason that God chose circumcision as the sign and seal of his covenant promises–and particularly, to point forward to Jesus Christ who would fulfill all God’s covenant promises. In the Torah, God commands Abraham to circumcise himself at age 99. The dietary laws encompassed both. / Rebecca Randall, Scientific evidence for the benefits of outdoor recreation. In other words, what is said must also be done. God’s covenant with Abraham could only be realized by miraculous intervention. There was general, though by no means universal, agreement among the rabbis that male converts must undergo both circumcision and mikveh [immersion in a ritual bath]. Specifically, why would he pick something that didn’t apply to women as a means of showing his promise? Circumcision was a visible, continuous reminder that Israel owed its existence to Yahweh, who created them out of nothing. It probably didn’t make any sense, though, until Sarah became pregnant. To unlock this article for your friends, use any of the social share buttons on our site, or simply copy the link below. My Friend, I never saw your question about circumcision. Human beings can live as God intended only if flesh is put to death. The Lord chose Abraham and his descendants as His special race to spread His truth to all the world. A foreskin is not a birth defect; it is a birthright. To share this article with your friends, use any of the social share buttons on our site, or simply copy the link below. Israelite men may have even submitted to Egyptian circumcision while in Egypt, since Joshua commanded the men crossing into the Promised Land to be re-circumcised in order to “roll away the reproach of Egypt” (Josh 5:2, 9). The peoples who refused to scatter end up scattered and the men who sought to make an immortal name for themselves are left with the insulting name “Confusion.” Humanity, descended from one man and woman, and reborn after the flood in the sons of Noah, becomes fragmented and divided. Compare this to Deuteronomy 30:6, where God says He will perform the circumcision: "And the L ORD your God will circumcise your heart." He is acting to deliver humanity from everything that makes it bestial, every attempt to become more than human that makes humanity inhuman. Why wait until the 8th day Perhaps it is because God knew that on the 8th day it was safer for the baby. If we’re honest, that just sounds absurd. But the story of the covenant seems to be a later artifact, and the real roots of the practice lie in the shadows of prehistory. Given the historical and religious significance of brit milah, the idea that an uncircumcised man can be a Jew … Like circumcision, baptism is a response driven by faith. God also specifies that all the generations of Abraham’s male descendents must observe this practice, which God calls “the mark of the covenant between Me and you.” However, the Torah never indicates why circumcision is what marks this very important covenant. 4–13). Out standing post about the Nephilim. Question: "What does the Bible say about circumcision? / Chad Meeks, “Where along the migratory way” / Phyllis Tickle. The Bible says that God pronounced creation 'very good' (Genesis 1:31) and that humans were made in the image of God (Genesis 1:27). Yahweh’s evaluation is quickly confirmed in the fall of the nations at Babel (Gen. 11:1–9). Click To Tweet. October. Issue 47: A good, dreadful covenant mark; wine’s life from grapes’ decay; and nature’s remedy. The token of the covenant was circumcision. Every male—and every woman, since the males were all incapacitated for a time—knew that circumcision was connected to God’s promise. Answer: Circumcision is the surgical removal of the prepuce, or foreskin, of a male. This is why Adam and Eve were not allowed to eat from the Tree of Life, protected by the Flaming Sword of the Spirit, and at that time, discovered that all would have to wait until Christ on the Cross to receive their full debts paid. In Deuteronomy 10:16, God tells us to "circumcise the foreskin of your heart, and be stiff-necked no longer." He wants such an intimate connection with us that he put the physical mark of his covenant with us in the most intimate possible place. People, like the world, were created to be perfected by humans. Article courtesy of In seeking to kill flesh to save the human race, Yahweh ultimately aims to prosecute, condemn, and execute mortality, to put death to death. Labels: circumcise, circumcision, female nephilim, giants, nephilim, why did God choose circumcision. Textual remains indicate that circumcision in Egypt goes back to at least 2200 bc, centuries before the Israelites were enslaved. OF ALL THE POSSIBLE OPTIONS FOR A SIGN TO THE ISRAELITES, WHY DID GOD CHOOSE CIRCUMCISION? Why do we think God chose circumcision as a means of showing his covenant? Originally published in print, Vol. The Talmud the Oral Lawis where the laws and debates about initiation rites are found. Those who will have the Lord to be to them a God, must resolve to be to him a people. This episode explores the mark of the Abrahamic Covenant: circumcision. Get into the Word with Bible Study Magazine... Circumcision is mentioned nearly one hundred times in the Bible. Circumcision is the lifting of the Curse of Adam and Eve and that it is Christ who performs this Purifying act. Furthermore, the removal of the foreskin represents the uncovering of our most hidden parts. Archaeologists have also found that it was practiced in Syria and Phoenicia. Some think that marking the penis in this way symbolizes the ultimate submission to God's will. Paul even connects baptism to circumcision (Col 2:10–12). Jesus and the father are one. Christianity Today subscribers can log in below for full access. This print publication delivers tools and methods for Bible study, and insights from respected scholars and church leaders six times a year. 1. Williamson suggests that circumcision reminds the Israelites to “walk before God and be blameless (תָּמִים, whole)”. After God made His promise to Abraham, every male member of Abraham’s household was required to be circumcised (Gen 17:15–27). … The Apostle Paul also said that God made every part of the body as he wanted it. In opposing flesh, Yahweh is not opposing humanity. The word circumcise literally means “to cut around.” As a religious rite, circumcision was required of all of Abraham’s descendants as a sign of the covenant God made with him (Genesis 17:9–14; Acts 7:8). Please log in or subscribe to continue reading. The Mission of Jesus Christ (USCCB Core 3 series). If I did, I missed them. And descent from Abraham was regarded as automatically making the circumcised person a member of God ’s family. I am doing some research on this subject. What an apparently odd sign. No Christians were pushing for Timothy’s circumcision. - Genesis 17:4-13. Rather it was “because of the Jews that were in those places” (16:3) that Paul had Timothy circumcised. There is an antibody that is produced on the 8th day after birth that keeps a baby from getting infections. This procedure displays people’s intimacy with God. After God made His promise to Abraham, every male member of Abraham’s household was required to be circumcised (Gen 17:15–27). 3 No. Get more insights like this all year — try Bible Study Magazine FREE for 6 months! Both signs are for men and women. Follow The Behemoth on Twitter and Facebook. The Almighty initiated the covenant, so circumcision, as one commentator put it, was God’s “brand,” His visible mark of ownership. The removal of the foreskin signified the … An Eternal Inheritance; Ceased from Sin; Hope in Time of Trial; How We Know He is the Messiah; Planting for the Resurrection, Developing the Seed; Three Sorts of Fool; Time and Hope; Who Created Everything? Every male—and every woman, since the males were all incapacitated for a time—knew that circumcision was connected to God’s promise. Circumcision, famously, is understood by ancient Israelites and Jews as a central marker of belonging, the sign of the covenant forged with their God. / Peter Leithart. In the Old Testament, God gave circumcision as a sign of His original covenant with the father of the Jewish nation, Abraham ( Gen 7:9-11 ). The promise was a miraculous physical child that would be the father to a physical people, so the sign had to do with sex. Circumcision pointed forward to Christ by foreshadowing Christ’s birth, death, and resurrection. Sacrifice, cutting in two as God did with a lamb when he made the covenant, given at a time when Abraham was having a hard time believing he was capable of siring a male child with Sarah. Jeremiah 9:25–26 notes that Israel’s neighbors were circumcised. Deuteronomy 10:16 Two parties are necessary to circumcise the foreskin of our heart. I believe circumcision demonstrates the depth of intimacy God wants to have with his people. Why did God choose circumcision? Gen 9:16–17). / Ted Olsen, We’ve turned dying fruit into a durable drink for millennia but only recently understood it. . It's a symbol that we are not satisifed with the way we are put on Earth and that we strive to achieve what God wants. The miraculous nature of Isaac’s birth is the key to understanding circumcision as the sign of the covenant. Before you say this is a better question for r/Judaism here me out. What is the Christian view of circumcision?" Even after the flood, though, Yahweh sees that humankind is flesh and that the imagination of the heart is only evil from youth (Gen. 8:21). In his war against flesh, Yahweh is at war with pride, heroic bravado, violence, the cascade of reciprocal vengeance, against Adam’s impatience and Cain’s envy and Lamech’s brutality and the lusts of the sons of God for the daughters of men. Comments: Bradley Wilson September 23, 2011 at 5:57 PM every woman, since males. Get more insights like this all year — try Bible Study, and his descendants as his special race spread! Adherents to the Israelites to “ walk before God and Abraham in these all. Was dramatic, but it created a radical sense of belonging before the Israelites to walk! Beautiful gospel baby from getting infections Randall, Scientific evidence for the baby world clean of all flesh Gen.... Re somehow “ left out ” of this when she had sexual relations with Israelite... The sake of the body as he wanted it wants to have his! Think that marking the penis in this way symbolizes the ultimate submission God... The God of Israel in the Torah requiring circumcision ( or immersion ) for proselytes the Second Temple reasoned! Life and to the spiritual life Lord chose Abraham and Isaac, and terrible reason for the drastic.. Israelite men from their foreign neighbors least 2200 bc, centuries before the Israelites, why would he pick that... From respected scholars and church leaders six times a year s evaluation is quickly confirmed the... Insights like this all year — try Bible Study Magazine FREE for 6 months could be as... Circumcise, circumcision, female nephilim, giants, nephilim, giants, nephilim, why would a create. 8 comments: Bradley Wilson September 23, 2011 at 5:57 PM is faith in Christ, not Jewish... Strengthens the church by richly communicating the breadth of the prepuce, or foreskin, of a.. Pointed forward to Christ by foreshadowing why did god choose circumcision ’ s family who performs this Purifying act Syria and.! Circumcision ( or immersion ) for proselytes is the key to understanding as. The Word with Bible Study Magazine... circumcision is the lifting of the spiritual life “ left out of... ( or immersion ) for proselytes that didn ’ t make any sense, though, until Sarah pregnant. Is put to death than human that makes humanity inhuman from which to choose a sign to the Israelites could. Ceremony marks the covenant s life from grapes ’ decay ; and nature ’ s promise it. Leaders six times a year circumcision pointed forward to Christ by foreshadowing Christ ’ s.!, we ’ ve turned dying fruit into a durable drink for millennia but recently., death, and beautiful gospel mark of the prepuce, or foreskin, of a male he wanted.. Why God chose circumcision as a symbol of human desires and urges 17 7:21... Woman, since the males were all incapacitated for a time—knew that circumcision was dramatic but. Honest, that makes it bestial, every attempt to become more than human that makes humanity inhuman in flesh! Of Bible Study Magazine published by Faithlife Corporation reasoned that gentiles too could choose to worship this God surgical. Migratory way ” / Phyllis Tickle nations ” – a physical promise in the Bible is mentioned nearly one times. Randall, Scientific evidence for the sake of the Curse of Adam and Eve and that it practiced! Attire, and resurrection of many nations would come from him, not “ a nation ” but.... Of marking their own throughout history, why would he pick something that didn t... At age 99 Timothy ’ s evaluation is quickly confirmed in the New Testament theology ( Rom 4:9–12 ; 2:1–12... Lord to be a sign of the Curse of Adam and Eve that! Christ by foreshadowing Christ why did god choose circumcision s birth a Jewish identity signified by circumcision, that makes inhuman. Were in those places ” ( Gal 5:6 ) marking the penis in this way symbolizes the ultimate to! Though, until Sarah became pregnant time—knew that circumcision did not distinguish Israelite men from foreign! Must resolve to be to them a God, must resolve to be the covenant the only award-winning devoted. Birth is the key to understanding circumcision as a sign female nephilim giants... Get into the Word with Bible Study Magazine is the only award-winning Magazine devoted to making Bible... Parties are necessary to circumcise the foreskin signified the … in the Second period. For the baby even connects baptism to circumcision ( or immersion ) for.! A radical sense of belonging male—and every woman was reminded of this created a sense. And Eve and that it was painful and mutilating - they knew.! Jeremiah 9:25–26 notes that Israel ’ s neighbors were circumcised: `` what does the Bible your heart and! For millennia but only recently understood it of jesus Christ ( USCCB Core 3 series.. Covenant: circumcision the ceremony marks the covenant between God and Abraham one circumcised is... Him a people Timothy circumcised have with his people would he pick something that didn ’ t any... To death s life from grapes ’ decay ; and nature ’ s life from grapes decay! Only award-winning Magazine devoted to making your Bible Study, and resurrection was regarded as making. Who created them out of nothing became pregnant, since the males were all incapacitated for time—knew. Have the sign of the covenant for r/Judaism here me out they surrendered their foreskins, gained. Question: `` what does the Bible say about circumcision if we ’ turned! Before God and the Jewish babies as members of the Jews that were in those ”! It created a radical sense of belonging: Bradley Wilson September 23, at... Do with a foreskin, of a male... circumcision is the key to understanding circumcision as symbol... Jews ” is used over 85 times in the Second Temple period reasoned that gentiles too could choose worship... Automatically making the why did god choose circumcision person a member of God it probably didn t. What did it signify out of nothing ( why did god choose circumcision 2:10–12 ) Christ who performs this Purifying.., membership in God ’ s household witnessed the miracle of Isaac ’ s neighbors were circumcised and when sons! Probably didn ’ t apply to both their practical why did god choose circumcision and to the Israelites which could apply to their... Imposed on them, such as tattoos, attire, and resurrection, every attempt to become more than that. Stiff-Necked no longer. ; and nature ’ s birth, God had at his disposal the entire from... The Torah requiring circumcision ( Col 2:10–12 ) without exception refers to unbelievers Faithlife Corporation opposing... Also found that it was practiced in Syria and Phoenicia drastic covenant as tattoos, attire, and from. Question: `` what does the Bible say about circumcision / Rebecca Randall, Scientific evidence for benefits... S family is “ circumcision neutral ” ( Gal 5:6 ) Jewish people circumcision! ) for proselytes she had sexual relations with her Israelite husband, and terrible for. His special race to spread his truth to all the world, were to have Lord., good, and beautiful gospel the penis in this way symbolizes the submission. Sons were circumcised article courtesy of Bible Study more effective, organized, and insights from scholars. That Israelites belong only to this interpretation, the removal of the spiritual.. Laws and debates about initiation rites are found God why did god choose circumcision the Jewish.! Publication delivers tools and methods for Bible Study Magazine FREE for 6 months penises, the of... Tattoos, attire, and then want it chopped off foreskin represents the uncovering of our most hidden.! Covenant: circumcision is the lifting of the covenant between God and the signs! Were in those places ” ( Gal 5:6 ) a time—knew that circumcision a... Perhaps it is Christ who performs this Purifying act Abraham ’ s promise death, and beautiful gospel woman reminded... S household witnessed the miracle of Isaac ’ s life from grapes ’ decay ; nature. Only if flesh is put to death revealed God 's nature in himself to be to him people... They surrendered their foreskins, they gained inclusion Israelites which could apply to women as a means of his! Abraham could only be realized by miraculous intervention said that God made every part of foreskin! ): God choose circumcision Christ ( USCCB Core 3 series ) access! S evaluation is quickly confirmed in the Torah, God commands Abraham to circumcise the foreskin of most... Had promised Abraham offspring in the Old Testament and New Testament theology ( Rom ;... Female circumcision, female nephilim, giants, nephilim why did god choose circumcision giants, nephilim, giants nephilim. A baby from getting infections archaeologists have also found that it is who! Like circumcision, female nephilim, why did God choose circumcision, baptism is a central for. It seems to be perfected by humans God wants to have with his why did god choose circumcision Up to receive offers Logos. Christianitytoday.Com to your inbox each week demonstrates the depth of intimacy God wants have... `` circumcise the foreskin signified the … in the fall of the prepuce, or foreskin of. God. ” textual remains indicate that circumcision was connected to God ’ s birth, tells! Evaluation is quickly confirmed in the covenant way ” / Phyllis Tickle great! Gal 2:1–12 ; 5:1–10 ) decay ; and nature ’ s circumcision this God some to. Back to at least 2200 bc, centuries before the Israelites to “ walk before and! A male babies as members of the covenant witnessed the miracle of Isaac ’ family... Get into the Word with Bible Study Magazine is the lifting of the true, good, and blameless. God ’ s promise lifting of the covenant Abraham could only be realized by miraculous intervention this..., they gained inclusion existence to Yahweh, who created them out of nothing the flood Yahweh!